A024 (Limit on Confidential Settlement Agreements)

House of Deputies Message #51

The House of Deputies informs the House of Bishops that on Jun 23, 2024 it considered resolution A024 (Limit on Confidential Settlement Agreements). The house acted to:

Adopt Substitute


Resolved, the House of Bishops concurring,

That the 81st General Convention enact Canon IV.14.14 as follows: 

<Amended text as it would appear if adopted and concurred. Scroll below the line of asterisks (******) to see the version showing all deleted and added text.> 

Sec. 14. No Accord or civil settlement agreement may prevent or restrict the disclosure of factual information related to any alleged Offense under this Title. Notwithstanding this Section, an Accord or civil settlement agreement may preclude the disclosure of the identity of an alleged Injured Person, or of an amount paid to settle a claim or obtain a release of civil liability. 

****** 
<Proposed amended resolution text showing exact changes being made:> 

Sec. 14: No Accord or civil settlement agreement may prevent or restrict the disclosure of factual information related to any alleged Offense under this Title. Notwithstanding this Section, an Accord or civil settlement agreement may preclude the disclosure of the identity of an alleged Injured Person, or of an amount paid to settle a claim or to obtain a release of civil liability. 

That the 81st General Convention recognizes the use and presence of Non-Disclosure Agreements, confidentiality provisions, and other contractual agreements between parties as legal and binding resolutions to civil matters and disciplinary within the general Church; and be it further,

Resolved, That this convention acknowledge such legal agreements are useful apparatuses for resolutions of misconduct actions and other actions involving bishops, clergy, and laity, including but not limited to actions initiated through the procedures in Title IV, especially when the Complainant and/or Injured Person is a minor or desires the binding confidentiality and terms a Non-Disclosure Agreement may provide; and be it further,

Resolved, That this convention recognizes Non-Disclosure Agreements have also been historically used to protect and hide evidence of patterns of predatory behavior, misconduct, and other serious offenses from being known by applicable church individuals and bodies, from ensuring that Complainants and/or Injured Persons have appropriate opportunities for healing, and that unduly burden those harmed by misconduct; and be it further,

Resolved, That past Conventions have directed the Standing Commission on Structure, Governance, Constitution and Canons to study the use of Non-Disclosure Agreements, confidentiality provisions, and other contractual agreements between parties used to resolve civil matters, other disciplinary issues, and matters begun through Title IV proceedings; to discover the frequency of use of these documents to resolve civil and Title IV matters of misconduct in the Church; the general nature of these documents and provisions; the impact of these documents on Complainants, Injured Persons, and victims of misconduct, as well as the impact on Respondents, especially when the impact of  these agreements has been to impede or obstruct the process of restoration, healing, and reconciliation, to which we are called as the Body of Christ; and be it further,

Resolved, That this convention reiterates the ongoing use and misuse of nondisclosure agreements within the church and directs the appropriate commission or body to study the use of these agreements and similar documents and report back to Executive Council with the statistical information and impact of the use of these and similar documents with recommendations for use of said Non-Disclosure Agreements and similar documents for use in the church; and be it further,

Resolved, That these findings shall be utilized by the Executive Council to make appropriate recommendations to amendments to Title IV presented to the subsequent General Convention and to develop guidelines for dioceses and chancellors for use of Non-Disclosure Agreements, confidentiality provisions, and other contractual agreements between parties documents to be distributed no later than December 1, 2026.

Resolved, That until a policy regarding their use is implemented by the appropriate ecclesiastical bodies, Non-Disclosure Agreements shall be used sparingly in the resolution of actions, and that they are not to be used to protect the individual or organization from the notoriety or information of misconduct, transgression, or wrongdoing, but instead should be used at the request of the Complainant and/or Injured Person as a part of restoration, healing, and reconciliation.